"Taraji P. Henson Steals the Spotlight in Tyler Perry’s Straw"
Starring Taraji P. Henson | Directed by Tyler Perry | Released on Netflix
---
Introduction: The Emotional Weight of “Straw”
Tyler Perry’s latest Netflix release, Straw, enters the cinematic landscape carrying the familiar themes of struggle, sacrifice, and social inequality — themes he often explores through the lens of Black womanhood. However, what makes Straw stand out is not just its heavy subject matter, but Taraji P. Henson’s heartbreaking and intense portrayal of a mother on the brink of collapse. This review takes a deep dive into the movie’s narrative strength, emotional depth, and its controversial treatment of trauma.
---
The Premise: A Mother at Her Breaking Point
In Straw, we follow the life of Janiyah, a hardworking single mother, played by Taraji P. Henson, who is stretched beyond her limits. Janiyah works three low-paying jobs while trying to care for her chronically ill daughter, maintain housing, and preserve her dignity in a system that seems designed to crush people like her.
Her reality is a reflection of countless underrepresented women in America — those who are overworked, underpaid, and constantly forced to choose between survival and self-respect. The story follows her slow emotional unraveling as her environment becomes more hostile, her body more exhausted, and her spirit increasingly defeated.
---
Character Analysis: Taraji P. Henson as Janiyah
Taraji P. Henson brings unmatched depth and humanity to the role of Janiyah. Her performance is raw, realistic, and completely absorbing. From the quiet moments of despair to the explosive breakdowns, she captures the exhaustion of a woman who is constantly being forced to hold everything together.
What’s remarkable about Taraji’s performance is how she doesn’t make Janiyah appear as a simple victim. Instead, she portrays her as a survivor, a fighter — someone who may be fragile, but is never weak. Her facial expressions, body language, and vocal tone evolve as the film progresses, showing the toll that constant struggle takes on a human being.
---
Narrative Structure: Realism vs. Repetition
The film’s plot unfolds like a slow-burning crisis. There’s no major twist or plot surprise; instead, Straw relies on the piling up of small injustices — an aggressive customer at work, a belittling manager, medical bills, traffic tickets, and unkind neighbors. It’s a narrative choice that mirrors real life, where people break not from one moment, but from the accumulation of many.
However, this narrative style is also a point of criticism. At times, the film becomes so relentlessly dark and hopeless that it feels emotionally manipulative. The repetition of suffering can become numbing rather than impactful, leaving the viewer drained instead of enlightened.
---
Themes and Social Commentary
Tyler Perry, through Straw, touches on multiple social and political issues:
✅ 1. Systemic Failure
Janiyah represents those who fall through the cracks of society — where no amount of hard work guarantees dignity or stability. The film critiques systems like healthcare, law enforcement, and labor markets that disproportionately affect the poor and marginalized.
✅ 2. Misogynoir
A term that describes the unique oppression faced by Black women, misogynoir is central to this story. Janiyah isn’t just poor; she is constantly disrespected, disbelieved, and dehumanized — not only because she is a woman, but because she is a Black woman.
✅ 3. Mental Health
The film shows how constant stress and trauma affect one’s mental stability. Janiyah's slow breakdown is not sudden or dramatic; it's quiet, believable, and deeply painful to watch.
✅ 4. The Strength of Motherhood
Despite everything, Janiyah remains fiercely protective of her daughter. This mother-daughter relationship brings warmth to the otherwise cold world around them. It’s this emotional bond that provides the film with its few hopeful moments.
---
Cinematography and Direction
The visual tone of the film is intentionally bleak — dull colors, tight spaces, and harsh lighting. While this adds to the oppressive mood, it also limits visual variety. Tyler Perry uses a straightforward directing style, focusing more on performances than stylistic flourishes. In some scenes, this works well; in others, it makes the film feel like a stage play with limited visual engagement.
One key sequence — where Janiyah finally breaks down and screams at a supervisor in a grocery store — is shot with minimal cuts, allowing Taraji’s performance to command the viewer’s full attention. It’s uncomfortable, intimate, and stunning.
---
Criticism of Perry’s Approach
While Tyler Perry should be credited for telling stories about Black women in hardship, many critics argue that his approach borders on trauma exploitation. Straw is no different — the emotional battering Janiyah receives is so constant that it leaves little room for nuance or development.
There are few supportive characters, no comic relief, and almost no scenes where the main character catches a break. This makes the film powerful but also painfully one-note.
Many viewers and critics feel Perry needs to evolve in his storytelling — adding more balance, growth, and multi-dimensional character arcs.
---
Audience Reaction: A Mixed Bag
Some viewers praise the film for its brutal honesty and for giving space to the everyday struggles of poor Black women. Others find it depressing and exhausting.
Taraji P. Henson, however, receives near-universal acclaim. Her performance is seen as Oscar-worthy, even if the film itself is not.
Social media discussions have raised questions like:
“Why are Black women always shown suffering in Perry’s films?”
“Is the message being lost in the trauma?”
“Would the film have been more powerful if it offered a glimmer of hope?”
---
Comparison to Other Tyler Perry Films
Compared to previous Perry films like Acrimony or Precious, Straw is more grounded in reality but less structured in its resolution. It doesn’t offer redemption, revenge, or even peace — just a quiet endurance.
It’s similar in tone to For Colored Girls, but even darker in outcome. The absence of healing or empowerment makes Straw feel more like a cautionary tale than a celebration of strength.
---
Final Thoughts: Is Straw Worth Watching?
Yes, but with caution.
Straw is not entertainment — it’s an emotional experience. It forces the viewer to feel uncomfortable and to recognize the cruelty of modern systems that fail the most vulnerable. It’s a film meant to spark conversations, not provide comfort.
If you’re looking for light-hearted drama or a traditional story arc, this isn’t it. But if you want a film that challenges your view of society and moves you with stellar acting, then Straw delivers — thanks entirely to Taraji P. Henson.
---
Conclusion: A Powerful Performance in a Painful Film
Straw is ultimately a showcase of one woman’s strength in the face of unrelenting adversity. While the film’s storytelling may not please everyone, it achieves one undeniable goal: making us feel.
And in that sea of emotion, Taraji P. Henson stands tall — a broken woman, a fierce mother, and an unforgettable character who speaks for the unseen and unheard.
